You’ve probably heard it a million times from financial “experts” – the key to financial success is saving. The idea is that if we save more now then we’ll have more to spend later. And while that’s true at the individual level it’s actually disastrous advice in the aggregate. Saving isn’t the key to financial success. Investing is the key to financial success. A lot of this is counterintuitive, but stick with me for a few minutes.
Saving is our unspent income. It is the residual of your income. And my spending is someone else’s income. So if I decide to save more then someone else has less income. All else equal, the economy has less spending power when I save more of my income. If we all saved more then we’d all have less income. So saving more can’t actually be the key to financial success because, in the aggregate, saving leads to lower incomes. That’s simple enough, right?
Investment (not the financial type you’re probably aware of with regard to buying stocks and bonds) is spending, not consumed, for future production. When you invest in your future you build an intangible (or tangible) asset that (likely) makes you more valuable. In other words, when you invest in yourself you make your future production more valuable which makes your future income more valuable which allows you to save more of your future income in the future.
The key point here, that most people don’t understand is that investment spending drives saving and not vice versa. For instance, if I have $100 in income and save $10 then that is $10 less that the aggregate economy can save. It’s the old paradox of thrift. We cannot all save in the aggregate and grow the economy. It’s a fallacy of composition to argue that we can all save and grow the economy. So, importantly, it is investment spending that adds to aggregate savings because one does not dissave in order to spend on investment. That is, when you invest you have an asset that is as valuable or more valuable than your prior saving PLUS someone else has your spending as their income. For example, if I spend $100 to build a factory for my business then I have spent $100 that someone else can earn as income AND I have a $100 asset that should enhance my future income. I have added to someone else’s income (and potential saving) without drawing down my own savings. If my factory is productive then the economy will grow and expand and our savings will revalue over time as my corporation becomes more valuable and adds to productive output.
So, next time some financial expert tells you that the key to financial success is saving more tell them they have their economics precisely backwards. The key to financial success isn’t saving, but investing in your own future production.
Mr. Roche is the Founder and Chief Investment Officer of Discipline Funds.Discipline Funds is a low fee financial advisory firm with a focus on helping people be more disciplined with their finances.
He is also the author of Pragmatic Capitalism: What Every Investor Needs to Understand About Money and Finance, Understanding the Modern Monetary System and Understanding Modern Portfolio Construction.